It's hard to create a truly detailed world. Usually it's not sold under some big buzzword though.
We're back!
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: Light DragonI'm not yet seeing the Bruce Sterling influences (Mirrorshades)
Quote from: Light DragonI can't say I buy your argument that the League of Nations could have kept Japan out of Manchuria. Barring the Russians getting involved I think Japan would have done fine.
In this world, presumably, their fleet wouldn't be limited to 30% the size of US and European fleets; so they could have built more firepower.
And their navy was fairly decent; they sank the chinese navy in 1896, and then the Russian Eastern navy in 1906. (Albeit, they caught both navies semi-unawares).
Quote from: Light DragonQuote from: Light DragonThe chinese would have likely had a strong anti-colonialist sentiment at this time after suffering the hardships of Japan, and then now defeating them. Why would they accept new masters?
As a necessary evil? As long as the Europeans behave themselves and secure the country, they may be accepted. The League is basically a benevolent force (indeed I believe it was much ahead of its time in our timeline, and in the Terran alternate timeline it does not suffer from inherent diplomatic deadlock). The Chinese are patient, I can imagine them waiting a few years to see how things develop. Either way, whether China is directly controlled or just accepts garrisons doesn't really make a difference in the timeline; the important part is that Europe uses the League charter to justify an intervention against Japan. This serves as a strong precedent and strengthens the League immensely.Quote from: Light DragonAnd I doubt the US would have wanted China to become a puppet of the Europeans- the US had long considered China to be a great nation- and in fact it allowed Madam Chiang to be the first female to address the US Congress on its floor, I believe.
The United States do not call the shots. In our timeline, WW1 allowed the US to emerge as a world power; in this timeline the US simply helped secure a stalemate - there was no victory in Europe for either side. The US is influential in setting up the League of Nations, and the League becomes a more powerful instrument in American diplomacy. In our timeline, the US never did join the League of Nations. Indeed, one could argue that a more balanced League of Nations might be more acceptable to the Chinese than one that is seen as a purely European instrument.Quote from: Light DragonSorry, I'm just really not buying the whole "League" could defeat Japan argument... Unless Russia and the US backed them with significant firepower in the 1930s.
Russia no, US yes.Quote from: Light DragonDon't worry though, it's impossible to satisfy every person who's going to try to historical nitpick your setting. I just wanted you to let you know I was reading and critically thinking about your ideas.
Thank you - I always welcome and appreciate constructive criticism. There's no reason to believe I can not improve the timeline!
---Quote from: Light DragonQuote from: Light DragonI suppose your opinion is that no one even thought to research it; that Einstein didn't publish his theories in the 1900s... but if he didn't do that, then how did they get space flight?
Einstein is necessary, and the Terrans will have to have a much better understanding of physics than we do (assuming that parallel worlds actually do exist and that travel to them is technically possible), although with that aspect I am of course veering off into the "weird sciences" realm. :)
The development of nuclear bombs by any nations would severely upset the balance of power on Terra, and I've included that scenario as a campaign idea in my third post; they just don't work in the default setting.
Thank you for taking the time to provide feedback!
- Nils
Page created in 0.094 seconds with 13 queries.