The Campaign Builder's Guild

Quote from: Steerpike
If we go with sea life Cthulhu MUST be the final rank.

Haha, of course Steerpike would want this.

I would be willing to compromise with "Kraken."

EDIT: How about mythical sea-life?

Mermaid
Siren
Nereid
Kappa
Cecaelia
Grindylow
Sea Serpent
Kraken
Leviathan

Mr. I-will-suck-your-life-out-through-the-butthole is stronger than a siren? :D

Sounds pretty scary to me.

But maybe the order needs work :P.

Quote from: Kalontas
Mr. I-will-suck-your-life-out-through-the-butthole is stronger than a siren? :D

I'm pretty sure I would be more afraid of someone who could suck my life essence out of my ass then some girl who can convince me to drown myself because she is a really good singer. At least with the second one I would die enjoying myself.

The 12 Olympians!

Demeter
Hephaestus
Aphrodite
Ares
Athena
Hermes
Artemis
Apollo
Dionysus
Poseidon
Hera
Zeus

Quote from: Nomadic

Quote from: Kalontas
Mr. I-will-suck-your-life-out-through-the-butthole is stronger than a siren? :D

I'm pretty sure I would be more afraid of someone who could suck my life essence out of my ass then some girl who can convince me to drown myself because she is a really good singer. At least with the second one I would die enjoying myself.

Stimulation of the posterior can be pleasurable...

Throw in a Selkie for good measure, and I'll support the vote the mythical sea-life.

Quote from: CoyoteCamouflage
Throw in a Selkie for good measure, and I'll support the vote the mythical sea-life.

Transforming into a Seal is kinda lame.

Quote from: Elemental_Elf

Quote from: CoyoteCamouflage
Throw in a Selkie for good measure, and I'll support the vote the mythical sea-life.

Transforming into a Seal is kinda lame.

But transforming into Seal is super-awesome. Because than Heidi Klum is your wife.

I modified Steerpike's list, because he had some things that were freshwater, and thus not Sea Life!

Mermaid  (Merman?  Merperson?  Merindividual?)
Hippocampus
Selkie
Siren
Sea Serpent
Kraken
Leviathan
Jormungandr (not sure on this one, since it's Unique, not a kind)
Zaratan

The Zaratan may not be the biggest, but it's a nice analogy for world-building or something blah blah turtle is best.

No one wants to see or be a Merman. #lamestmonsterever

Quote from: Polycarp
I modified Steerpike's list, because he had some things that were freshwater, and thus not Sea Life!

Mermaid  (Merman?  Merperson?  Merindividual?)
Hippocampus
Selkie
Siren
Sea Serpent
Kraken
Leviathan
Jormungandr (not sure on this one, since it's Unique, not a kind)
Zaratan

The Zaratan may not be the biggest, but it's a nice analogy for world-building or something blah blah turtle is best.

Let's not forget the homegrown awesomeness (in no particular order, save that the last 2 aren't really sea life and the one before them is technically more magically animated than alive):

Sea Worg
Koefhonar
Stormwyrm
Iid-Horror
Gnomish Ship-Breaker
Blackwater

(See http://www.thecbg.org/index.php/topic,46911.msg46911.html#msg46911 - I can't find the contest results here, and it doesn't look like the E-zine issue ever got published - Spring 08 is the only one I can find reference to anywhere. Believe it or not, you can still download that one from (!!!) http://www.fantaseum.com/zines.html (!!!))

Quote from: Elemental_Elf

Quote from: Nomadic

Quote from: Kalontas
Mr. I-will-suck-your-life-out-through-the-butthole is stronger than a siren? :D

I'm pretty sure I would be more afraid of someone who could suck my life essence out of my ass then some girl who can convince me to drown myself because she is a really good singer. At least with the second one I would die enjoying myself.

Stimulation of the posterior can be pleasurable...

That's a different list.
*heh*

I would enjoy being a Gnomish Ship Breaker!